The case for & against
Bull & Bear analysis
Bullish
Hagerty, Inc. (NYSE: HGTY) is a leading player in the automotive insurance sector, specializing in coverage for classic and collector vehicles. The company operates within a niche market that caters to automotive enthusiasts through its unique membership model, which includes not only insurance services but also a marketplace for auctions and sales. As the collector car market appreciates, Hagerty is positioned to benefit from a growing community of car lovers seeking specialized insurance solutions.
Bull says
- ↑Q1 premiums $289 M (+18% YoY); adjusted EBITDA $85 M (+77% YoY)
- ↑89% policy retention highlights strong loyalty in niche collector market
- ↑State Farm and Liberty Mutual partnerships driving premium growth across 40 states
- ↑$212 M cash on hand funds tech investments and marketplace expansion
- ↑High earnings yield and strong profitability factor imply attractive valuation
- ↑Low short interest and positive momentum support a favourable outlook
Bear says
- ↓GAAP net loss of $41 M–$51 M forecast for 2026 from acquisition-cost amortization
- ↓Negative growth indicators and bearish analyst revisions signal scaling challenges
- ↓Delayed State Farm policy conversions risk slowing premium momentum
- ↓Volatile standard-auto rate hikes may spur consumer shopping, pressuring margins
- ↓Unfavourable momentum and liquidity factors suggest execution and trading risks
Earnings Call · Q1 2026 · Mgmt. Guidance
Updated 05-12-2026neutral
Transcript signals
Bull points
- this year, 2026, and then 2027 are going to be big years for state farm conversion.
- between new and converted, we're already in excess of 100,000 policies. But in total, it's, you know, 500 plus thousand policies. So that is a meaningful driver this quarter and will be this year and next year.
- The underlying business is performing very well.
Bear points
- gap net loss of $13 million.
- First quarter loss before taxes was $21 million and includes $89 million of deferred acquisition costs.
- First quarter net loss was $13 million, and net loss attributable to Class A common shareholders was $7 million.
Read full transcript analysis ›